Florida Court Rules Couple Not Allowed to Grow Vegetables in Their Own Front Yard

e4cf851f05262c89b5169c8bceab261f?s=196&r=pg
Majority Owner of The AEGIS Alliance. I studied in college for Media Arts, Game Development. Talents include Writer/Article Writer, Graphic Design, Photoshop, Web Design and Development, Video Production, Social Media, and eCommerce.

(ANTIMEDIA) — A Florida couple recently lost yet another battle with their local government in their efforts to protect their right to grow vegetables in their front yard.

Hermine Ricketts and her husband Tom Carroll grew vegetables in their front yard for seventeen years, mostly because their backyard did not receive enough sunlight to sustain their garden. But in May of 2013, the local government of Miami Shores passed an ordinance banning the practice.

Though the ordinance allowed fruit, trees, and garden gnomes and flamingos to remain in front yards, vegetable gardens were outlawed. Property owners were permitted to grow them elsewhere on their property, but the ordinance asserted its right to declare vegetable gardens in the front yard unsightly. The city council claimed it was “protecting the distinctive character of Miami Shores Village.”

Within days, code enforcers came to their property, issued a citation, and threatened to fine them $50 per day if they didn’t eradicate their crops of okra, kale, lettuce, onion, spinach, and dozens of other plants. The couple could not afford the hefty fine and was forced to dismantle their garden

They pleaded with the Miami Shores Code Enforcement Board on two occasions but to no avail.

Represented by the Institute for Justice, a constitutional advocacy organization, Ricketts and Carroll eventually sued the city, kicking off a years-long battle. Last year, circuit judge Monica Gordo sided with the local government.

The couple alleged the ordinance violated their rights under the Florida constitution. CBS Miami  summarized that they “argued that the ordinance ran afoul of the Florida Constitution, including that it violated their privacy rights and their right to acquire, possess and protect property.”

Gordo disagreed. Even as she acknowledged that she wasn’t sure how their garden disturbed the aesthetics of the neighborhood, she maintained the government’s right to decide what was visually acceptable.

Given the high degree of deference that must be given to a democratically elected governmental body … Miami Shores’ ban on vegetable gardens outside of the backyard passes constitutional scrutiny,” she wrote last August.

The couple then contested her decision, taking it to an appeals court. This month, however, a three-judge panel sided with the government yet again, affirming that the ordinance is constitutional. The panel also cited “legal precedents upholding zoning regulations based on aesthetics.”

But as the Institute for Justice previously observed:

Hermine and Tom never set out to violate the law.  The idea of making productive use of their property to grow food just seemed like a smart, economical thing to do. In Miami Shores, however, that sort of self-sufficiency—always a hallmark of the American character—is against the law.”

The Institute for Justice told Anti-Media on Monday that it is reviewing its options moving forward in fighting for Ricketts’ and Carrol’s right to grow food on their own property.

by Carey Wedler / Creative Commons / Anti-Media / Report a typo

e4cf851f05262c89b5169c8bceab261f?s=96&r=pg
Kyle James Leehttp://theaegisalliance.com
Majority Owner of The AEGIS Alliance. I studied in college for Media Arts, Game Development. Talents include Writer/Article Writer, Graphic Design, Photoshop, Web Design and Development, Video Production, Social Media, and eCommerce.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Please consider giving us a monetary contribution toward important projects and to continue operating via Crypto. We also accept PayPal and Checks by mail.

  • bitcoin Bitcoin
  • ethereum Ethereum
  • bitcoin cash Bitcoin cash
  • litecoin Litecoin
  • dash Dash
  • eos Eos
  • ethereum classic Ethereum classic
  • zcash Zcash
Scan to Donate Bitcoin to 35fJFcE1xQPwt1KujXUrmKn9J8WEnm9BbM

Contribute Bitcoin to this address

Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Bitcoin

Scan to Donate Ethereum to 0x2764fe441CB5EBd9919eDAD4b2Bf70Dc2dC399Da

Contribute Ethereum to this address

Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Ethereum

Scan to Donate Bitcoin cash to qr9j84dx9736ultjr7ty2dcr5rl27z5m2vx0hjqw57

Contribute Bitcoin cash to this address

Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Bitcoin cash

Scan to Donate Litecoin to MKVu1osxKsRSBc7U2NdgdYnyjMPanMUxx9

Contribute Litecoin to this address

Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Litecoin

Scan to Donate Dash to XuHFuU7mpyRAm8WbtUK54Ws7bVTcQgK8vd

Contribute Dash to this address

Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Dash

Scan to Donate Eos to coinbasebase (944543472)

Contribute Eos to this address

Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Eos

Scan to Donate Ethereum classic to 0x19D64fb43a316d8A87230e596746D87a8345075B

Contribute Ethereum classic to this address

Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Ethereum classic

Scan to Donate Zcash to t1Ud7hP7J9FsopMSZU5vShe68PWos2Fha3D

Contribute Zcash to this address

Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Zcash

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

*

indicates required

/ ( mm / dd )

We Accept Monetary Contributions Toward Our Important Projects

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

*

indicates required

/ ( mm / dd )

Related Articles